Skip to main content

Comic Strips : Winsor McCay & Bill Watterson

This week's reading is a series of comic strips from Little Nemo in Slumberland by Winsor McCay and Calvin and Hobbes by Bill Watterson.
While I grew up on Calvin and Hobbes, I had only heard mention of McCay's work. So, I decided to read both comics to see how they would compare as two strips featuring the adventures of a young boy.

Breaking into McCay's work was very surprising. I was expecting traditional pen-and-ink strips, but instead found a comic in which each panel is its own painstakingly designed, full-color illustration.
McCays's style is strongly informed by classical illustrators. His work joins the curving designs of art nouveau with Maxfield Parrish's lush classical backdrops. While these illustrators' work was quite realistic, however, the world of Slumberland is abound with highly designed creatures. 

While cartoonists tend to caricature, McCay truly takes his designs one more step forward. One character from McCay's strip featured above looks like she could have stepped out of the Hayao Miyazaki film Spirited Away:
The look of McCay's work is, of course, vastly different from the ink-brushed, loops-and-lines look of Calvin and Hobbes. Aside from the art, however, I found the content to be very different as well. 

In Little Nemo in Slumberland, Nemo goes on surreal and very escapist journeys into new lands. He only experiences reality at the very end of the strip, when he wakes. By contrast, Calvin and Hobbes is entirely set in a satirized version of the trials and tribulations of a boy's everyday life.
How the characters navigate their respective worlds is opposite as well. While Calvin gets himself into trouble constantly and must find a way to wiggle out of it, this is not so in Slumberland. Instead, Little Nemo seems to be propelled from one event to another through almost no will of his own.

Although these comic strips are very different from each other, they are each fantastic works. After experiencing them both, I definitely have a broader view on what the comic strip can achieve.



Comments

Popular posts from this blog

European Comics: Blacksad

Today I read the first book of  Blacksad , an edgy French comic written by Juan Diaz Canales and illustrated by Juanjo Guarnido. The   comics follow a panther detective through a series of anthropomorphic noir mysteries. I really enjoyed Blacksad . The story is a fairly standard mystery, but Blacksad's voice is engaging and authentic as a noir narrator, and the artwork is amazing. I felt that the art style was especially effective because it helps immediately establish character personalities--the criminals are rats and scaly creatures, the sheriff is a border collie, etc. I also tend to find that in noir movies or comics all the characters tend to look the same (all the men are square-jawed and serious, the women attractive and curvy) and the style of  Blacksad helped prevent this from happening for me. Guarnido also does a fantastic job at using different shot angles and engaging acting within the panels. I enjoy this kind of visual storytelling much ...

The Future of Comics: Electric Sheep

When I opened   The First Word of Patrick Farley's Electric Sheep comics , I was expecting a standard webcomic. I was very surprised that instead of formatting itself as a "normal" comic,   The First Word  is a sidescroller that uses simple lighting effects and motion design. This was entirely new to me–I thought standard webcomics were considered fairly modern, but this felt like something completely different. I enjoyed how Farley seemed to be playing around so much with new media to explore what a comic is. It really opened me up to think about what new possibilities might be with merging traditional storytelling and technology. The transitions were especially amazing to me, like the stream of different animals evolving. I did think Farley went very over-the-top with the lighting effects when sex came into play (I found the comic hard to take seriously at that point), but overall, the use of art was definitely something to study. One area where the comic f...

The Killing Joke: Questions

Answers to the in-class reading questions. 1. What is your reaction to the text you just read (Batman: The Killing Joke)? I enjoy comics with more of a serious tone, and this was one of them. While I've seen the Batman universe portrayed pretty grimly, however, I was shocked by just how dark The Killing Joke gets--Gordon is dragged naked by a collar and is shown nude photos of his daughter after she was shot. This was much more sexually explicit than I am used to seeing with big name comics like Batman, too. I've seen sex scenes in these comics, but not sex used as the disturbing element it is in The Killing Joke. 2. What connections did you make with the story? Discuss the elements of the story with which you were able to connect. One thing I enjoyed a lot about The Killing Joke was the pacing and the switches between the present and the past in the Joker's life. The comic set up a good mystery within both timelines that really drew me in and made me want to kee...